Dining at the Pass One Square Edinburgh

One evening not long before Christmas, four bloggers make their way to a very exclusive table. A table for four no more, no less. We made our way through the lounge, not quite as far as the dining room, through doors almost as if we were leaving the premises. Ahh, we’ve arrived. We’re dining in the kitchen!

Downhill Farm Beets with Paddy's Millstone

Downhill Farm Beets with Paddy’s Millstone

Chef Webster, Executive Chef at One Square, the Sheraton Hotel, Edinburgh has invited us to experience what must be the most exclusive “table” in Edinburgh. Just four people can sit and enjoy a seven course menu specially devised by Malcolm “Dining at the Pass”. We’re to have a bird’s eye view of what goes on at the pass and watch our dishes being created. We’re also trying wines and cocktails created specially to complement the menu.

I think we were all a bit giggly before we began. It was fun to be somewhere diners would never venture. I had a bit of a challenge getting up onto the chair. They’re deliberately tall to make sure we don’t miss a thing but not easy for a small person!

St Bride's Farm Duck consome and faggots

St Bride’s Farm Duck consome and faggots

Welcome to dining at the pass with Erika, yours truly, Hilary and Nadine.

I think Gordon Ramsay and Marco Pierre White have a lot to answer for. It’s the first thing that people always ask when you mention you’ve been into a a professional kitchen. “Was there a lot of noise and swearing?” Whilst I can’t vouch for every restaurant, those ones I have been in have been calm with each person focussed on their task as to swearing? Not when I’ve been around. Chef Webster confirms “Yes this, is as noisy as it gets. The ordering system helps particularly, it’s transmitted electronically so that the waiters do not have to come in and out of the kitchen”.

Preparing the halibut

Preparing the halibut. Topped with foie gras foam, grapefruit and avocado

The kitchen is vast. The Sheraton can serve 500 diners in one sitting but tonight it’s standard service. Diners are eating a festive menu, we watch each dish being beautifully finished off at the pass just to the right of where we are sitting. Ahead are all manner of stoves, grills, pots pans and equipment. We’re pleasantly warm, but not overly so. Induction hobs are used throughout the kitchen keeping the heat level down to a reasonable level.

Venison with squash, chicory and chocolate

Venison with squash, chicory and chocolate

There’s a pleasing focus on local ingredients, with some more exotic additions. St Bride’s ducks, Downhill Farm beetroot and Paddy’s Millstone and smoked Cuddy’s Cave to mention but a few. You can imagine, there were plenty of sighs of delight from the three of us!

Smoked Cuddy's Cave with quince

Smoked Cuddy’s Cave with quince

I’m a big fan of tasting menus. I love the portion size and being inquisitive I like to try as many dishes as possible. For me, the dishes that really sang that evening where ones featuring the fewest ingredients – my all time favourites were the beetroot dish and the duck consomme (I could eat that forever). Thezs dishes really showcased their provenance. The wines and cocktails were expertly chosen to complement the dishes.

Just when I thought I could eat no more, an inspired cheese on toast really hit the spot.

The highlight of the meal (and there were many to choose from) was the spectacular dessert. We were asked to retire to the lounge whilst the scene was set. We arrived back at the pass to see our chefs standing at the pass with many small dishes lined up. They then proceeded to paint the granite with our dessert. And then, a huge chocolate egg was “thrown” into the mix and cinder toffee, raspberry granola, popping candy tumbled out. There was so many different tastes, textures and flavours to sample.  Each pair of us were determined not to leave a thing. What an amazing end to a very special meal.

Watch the video to see how the dish was created.

Dining at the pass menu

Dining at the pass menu


Dining at the Pass costs £80 per person or with matching wines £130. Booking essential.

Sheraton Hotel

One Square Bar and Restaurant
1 Festival Square
Edinburgh, EH3 9SR

Telephone: 0131 229 9131

Follow the Sheraton Grand Hotel & Spa, Edinburgh, on Twitter.
Like the Sheraton Grand Hotel & Spa, Edinburgh, on Facebook.

One Square on Twitter

Chef Webster on Twitter

Erika blogs at Little Mummy, Hilary blogs at MyMonkfish Nadine blogs at Eating Edinburgh

Many thanks to MyMonkfish  for the photo of the ultimate dessert below.

The Ultimate Dessert

The Ultimate Dessert Copyright MyMonkfish 2013

Last updated by at .

About Bread Baker Danielle

Danielle founded Edinburgh Foody in 2010. Having qualified as a professional bread baker in France in 2014, she is now on a new adventure in Gloucestershire. Check out severnbites.com Look out for occasional posts for Edinburgh Foody


  1. Pingback: Spend Valentine's in not out | Edinburgh Foody

  2. Does the chef give credit to Grant Achatz at Alinea for this dessert? It seems to me either a remarkable coincidence or he’s just nicked the concept of the dish…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.